MindLAB Neuroscience Neuroscience-based Life Coaching logo featuring a polygonal brain icon.

Why Am I So Indecisive? 10 Methods That Can Help You Make Decisions Confidently

a woman holding two balls

Indecisiveness has MANY neuroscience-related causes, but you can get better at making decisions, big and small, with practice and time. Whether it’s a major decision, such as choosing a life partner, or a minor decision, such as what to eat for breakfast, being indecisive can significantly impact your life. If you are always second guessing your decisions, or constantly seeking advice, this article will be tremendously helpful for you.

The Evolutionary Roots of Indecisiveness

From an evolutionary perspective, indecisiveness can be traced back to our ancestral survival mechanisms. In the face of potential threats or risks, indecisiveness may have served as a protective mechanism, allowing our ancestors to pause and carefully evaluate their options before taking action. This hesitation could have prevented them from making rash decisions that might have compromised their safety or survival.

  1. Risk Aversion: Indecisiveness may have evolved as a risk-averse strategy to avoid potential dangers or losses. In uncertain or ambiguous situations, our ancestors may have been more inclined to delay decision-making until they had gathered sufficient information or resources to mitigate potential risks.
  2. Cognitive Biases: Certain cognitive biases, such as loss aversion and the status quo bias, may have evolutionary roots that contribute to indecisiveness. These biases reflect a tendency to prefer the current state of affairs over potential changes, even when those changes could be beneficial.
  3. Social Dynamics: In the context of group living and social hierarchies, indecisiveness may have served as a means of avoiding conflict or maintaining social cohesion. Delaying decisions or deferring to others in the group could have been an adaptive strategy for preserving group dynamics and reducing interpersonal tensions.
  4. Environmental Uncertainty: In environments characterized by scarcity or unpredictability, indecisiveness may have been advantageous, allowing our ancestors to conserve resources and energy until more favorable conditions arose or until they had gathered sufficient information to make informed decisions.

While indecisiveness may have conferred evolutionary advantages in certain contexts, it can become maladaptive in modern societies where rapid decision-making and adaptability are often valued. Understanding the evolutionary roots of indecisiveness can provide insights into its underlying mechanisms and inform strategies for overcoming this tendency in contemporary settings.

The Neuroscience of Indecisiveness

Indecisiveness can be a symptom of various mental health conditions, such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). From a neuroscientific perspective, indecisiveness is often linked to imbalances or dysfunctions in certain brain regions and neurotransmitter systems.

  1. Prefrontal Cortex: The prefrontal cortex is responsible for decision-making, problem-solving, and cognitive control. Individuals with impaired prefrontal cortex function may struggle with indecisiveness due to difficulties in weighing options, anticipating consequences, and making rational choices.
  2. Dopamine System: Dopamine is a neurotransmitter involved in motivation, reward processing, and decision-making. Disruptions in dopamine signaling can lead to indecisiveness, as individuals may have difficulty assigning value to different options or experiencing the motivation to commit to a decision.
  3. Amygdala: The amygdala plays a crucial role in processing emotions, particularly fear and anxiety. Overactivation of the amygdala can contribute to indecisiveness by amplifying the fear of making the wrong choice or the anxiety associated with decision-making.
  4. Serotonin System: Serotonin is a neurotransmitter involved in regulating mood, impulse control, and decision-making. Low levels of serotonin have been linked to indecisiveness, as individuals may struggle with impulsivity or have difficulty weighing the consequences of their choices.
A man leaning against a wall
I have no idea what to do. Help!

10 Methods That Can Help You Become More Decisive

Here are 10 methods I teach my clients that just may help you become more decisive.

  1. Make decisions for yourself: Asking 10 people about one topic will only confuse you further. Ultimately, if you trust your intuition, you will know what the right decision is.
  2. Develop your confidence: When you make a choice, trust your intuition that it’s the right decision for yourself. Avoid second-guessing. If you have the confidence to trust yourself, you’ll find making and sticking to decisions much easier.
  3. Let things go: The fear that comes with worrying about making the “wrong” decisions can be paralyzing. Try not to worry about mistakes — they’re a part of life. Once you accept that things are not always in your control, making decisions will be much less threatening.
  4. Choose one person that can act as a sounding board: There will be instances when you’re truly stumped. When feeling stuck, ask a supportive friend or partner to weigh in.
  5. Talk it out: The simple act of speaking out loud will help alleviate indecision and internal conflict. If it feels right, voice your thoughts out loud to a friend or partner. Decisions can become less confusing and worrisome when we voice our fears and choices out loud.
  6. Narrow it down: If you’re facing a variety of options, take a practical approach. Narrow down your selections to three options with a ‘surgical slice.’ Don’t question yourself. Then evaluate the final three options and pick one.
  7. Outline the pros and cons: If you get stuck, draft a simple pro-con list. But the important thing to remember is to write it down. Mentally weighing the pros and cons is simply adding to the indecisiveness. Pro-con lists facilitate objective and sound decision making.
  8. Flip a coin: Of course, this method shouldn’t be used for big decisions, such as marriage. But this will work if it’s something as simple as what to order on the menu. This simple trick (which I use often) makes the decision for you. What’s interesting about flipping a coin is that your reaction will actually reveal what you truly want.
  9. Avoid questioning your final decision: Once you’ve made the decision, avoid second-guessing yourself. Simply embrace your selection and move forward.
  10. Recognize and celebrate your decisions: Congratulate yourself for every decision you make. Practice a kind, validating affirmation. For example, you might say, “I made a great decision. I’m getting better at making choices! This feels good!” If a negative voice tries to step in to create self-doubt, simply repeat your kind, validating words.
A group of papers with question marks on them
No more “what should i do’s”

The Low Down

Indecisiveness can stem from various factors, including evolutionary adaptations, neurological imbalances, and cognitive biases. However, by leveraging neuroscience-based strategies and coaching, individuals can overcome this challenge and develop greater confidence in their decision-making abilities. Neuroscience-based coaching offers a comprehensive approach, combining techniques such as neurofeedback, cognitive restructuring, mindfulness, and goal-setting to address the underlying neural mechanisms and cognitive patterns contributing to indecisiveness. Through personalized interventions targeting specific brain regions and neurotransmitter systems, coaches can provide tailored strategies to help individuals regain control over their decision-making processes. By cultivating emotional regulation, cognitive flexibility, and self-awareness, individuals can navigate life’s choices with clarity, confidence, and resilience, unlocking their full potential for personal growth and success.

Share this post

Picture of Dr. Sydney Ceruto

Dr. Sydney Ceruto

A Pioneer in Neuroscience-Based Coaching

As the founder of MindLAB Neuroscience, Dr. Sydney Ceruto has been a leading force in integrating neuroscience into coaching and counseling for over two decades. With three master's degrees in psychology and two PhDs in behavioral and cognitive neuroscience, she is widely considered a top expert in her field.

Harnessing the power of neuroscience-based coaching, Dr. Ceruto's innovative approach focuses on neuroscience, neuroplasticity, and neural pathway rewiring to foster lasting positive change in mental health.

Dr. Ceruto holds esteemed memberships in the Forbes Executive Council, Positive Performance Alliance, Wharton Executive Education Program, the International Society of Female Professionals, and executive writing positions for Alternatives Watch, Brainz Magazine, and TED: Ideas Worth Spreading.

Dr. Ceruto's accomplishments include:

  • The 2022 CREA Award.
  • A lead research position at NYU Steinhardt.
  • Volunteer work with Covenant House and the National Alliance for Mental Health (NAMI).

Her science-backed method of Neural Rewiring has successfully guided thousands of clients toward happier, more productive, and more resilient lives.